Mets Throw Nearly $1 Billion Down the River? Sign the biggest contract in history but still at risk of losing playoff dreams!
The New York Mets have made blockbuster moves this offseason, pulling out all the stops to become a World Series contender. The biggest splash? Their record-breaking signing of Juan Soto. Mets owner Steve Cohen secured Soto with the largest contract in sports history, surpassing even Shohei Ohtani’s $700 million deal with the Dodgers.
Soto’s contract is a staggering $765 million, proving that Cohen is willing to spend whatever it takes to chase a championship. But adding Soto was just the beginning. The Mets have also signed key players like Sean Manaea, Jesse Winker, and Jared Young to bolster their roster.
You’d think that with baseball’s most expensive player and an all-star supporting cast, the Mets would be a lock for the postseason. Shockingly, that’s not the case.
Despite a $950M Spending Spree, Mets’ Playoff Odds Are Underwhelming
According to Codify Baseball, the Mets only have a 57.5% chance of making the playoffs in 2025. That’s an alarming number considering Cohen has already spent nearly $954.45 million on free agents this offseason—the most by any team.
A staggering portion of that budget is tied to Juan Soto, yet even with his bat in the lineup, experts remain skeptical. The Mets’ low playoff odds raise serious questions:
- Will the team’s chemistry click in time?
- Is the Mets’ rotation strong enough to compete?
- Can Soto’s presence alone make up for other potential weaknesses?
Pitching Woes Could Derail the Mets’ Postseason Hopes
One major concern holding the Mets back is their starting rotation. Injuries have plagued their pitching staff, and while they’ve added depth, consistency remains a question mark. A powerful offense means nothing if the team can’t keep opponents’ runs in check.
Even with their historic spending, the Mets still have gaps to fill. Will their massive payroll pay off, or will Mets fans be left heartbroken once again?
Pete Alonso’s Future: The Next Big Mets Dilemma
With spring training approaching, another major storyline looms over the Mets—Pete Alonso’s contract situation. The slugger has yet to reach an agreement with the team, sparking speculation about a potential departure.
While some believe Alonso will re-sign with the Mets, others think he could be lured away by the Toronto Blue Jays, who have shown significant interest.
Will Alonso stay or bolt for Toronto?
According to Bleacher Report’s Kerry Miller, the most likely outcome is that Alonso remains in New York on a deal worth around six years, $174 million. However, a shorter-term offer—possibly three years, $75 million—could also be on the table.
For the Mets, keeping Alonso alongside Soto would create a lethal offensive duo. But if he walks away, it could throw another wrench into Cohen’s championship ambitions.
Are the Mets a Superteam or an Expensive Disaster?
If the Mets lock in Alonso, they could transform into a National League powerhouse, rivaling even the Los Angeles Dodgers. But if the chemistry doesn’t come together and their pitching struggles continue, they might become the biggest disappointment of 2025—despite their billion-dollar gamble.
Will the Mets’ spending spree pay off, or are they doomed for another heartbreaking season? Mets fans, buckle up—this ride is far from over.
