Detroit Tigers’ Backup Plan if They Fail to Sign Alex Bregman

The Detroit Tigers remain a top contender in the race to sign Alex Bregman, but with spring training fast approaching, the star third baseman remains unsigned. While Detroit appears to have made the most competitive offer in terms of contract length, Bregman’s hesitation raises questions about whether he truly sees himself in the Motor City.

If the Tigers fail to land Bregman, they need a solid backup plan for the third base position. One emerging option could be veteran infielder Justin Turner, who has drawn interest from the Tigers, Chicago Cubs, and Boston Red Sox.

Why Justin Turner Could Be the Right Fit

At 40 years old, Justin Turner wouldn’t command a long-term deal, making him a short-term solution while allowing top prospect Jace Jung to develop further. Unlike a long-term commitment to Bregman, a one-year deal for Turner would give the Tigers flexibility for future roster moves while still strengthening their infield.

Despite his age, Turner remains productive. In 2024, he played for both the Toronto Blue Jays and Seattle Mariners, hitting .259 with an OPS of .737 and an impressive on-base percentage of .354. This followed a standout 2023 season with the Boston Red Sox, where he blasted 23 home runs, tallied 96 RBIs, and maintained an OPS over .800.

The Value of a Veteran Presence

Turner’s addition wouldn’t be as electrifying as signing Bregman, but his experience and leadership could be invaluable to the Tigers’ young clubhouse. A two-time All-Star and 2020 World Series champion with the Los Angeles Dodgers, Turner brings a wealth of postseason experience and a disciplined approach at the plate.

While Turner may not push the Tigers into immediate championship contention, his presence would bolster the lineup and provide the kind of veteran stability that could prove crucial over a grueling 162-game season. Moreover, he fits the profile of the right-handed hitter that Scott Harris, the Tigers’ president of baseball operations, has been targeting this offseason.

What’s Next for Detroit?

As the Bregman sweepstakes continue, the Tigers’ front office must prepare for all possibilities. If they manage to land Bregman, they secure one of the top third basemen in baseball for years to come. If not, a short-term deal for Turner would be a smart contingency plan that keeps their roster competitive without sacrificing financial flexibility.

Regardless of the outcome, the Tigers’ offseason strategy will play a pivotal role in shaping their future as they aim to compete in the AL Central and beyond.