Amanda Serrano vs. Katie Taylor: A Rivalry That Redefines Women’s Boxing
image 674676a148e95.webp
Few matchups in women’s boxing generate as much excitement as Amanda Serrano vs. Katie Taylor. These two champions represent contrasting styles: Serrano’s powerful punches and aggressive pressure collide with Taylor’s quick combinations and slick footwork. But with two fights behind them, fans are asking—why do the scorecards keep leaning Taylor’s way?
Power vs. Speed: Who Really Wins?
Serrano brings relentless power to every fight, landing heavy shots that punish her opponents. In their first matchup, her dominant fifth round nearly stopped Taylor, and in the rematch, she sent Taylor staggering in the opening round. But with only two-minute rounds and constant clinches breaking up the action, Serrano wasn’t able to finish the job.
Taylor thrives in fast-paced exchanges, using speed and precision to pile up points. Judges have favored her approach, awarding her two close decisions. However, Serrano’s fans are frustrated, especially since she outlanded Taylor in power punches during the rematch.
The real question is: Is the judging in women’s boxing rivalries truly fair?
Amanda Serrano’s Legacy: More Than a Rivalry
Let’s not forget: Amanda Serrano is a trailblazer. She’s dominated across weight classes, moving seamlessly from bantamweight to lightweight, and even made history fighting in 12 three-minute rounds—a format rare in women’s boxing. Yet, her career is often reduced to those two losses to Taylor.
The clock is ticking for a trilogy. Taylor, now 38, is also tied up in another rivalry with Chantelle Cameron. If she fights Cameron again, she’ll be pushing 39 by the time Serrano gets her shot. And even if they meet for a third fight, can they still deliver the fireworks that made the first two fights instant classics?
While Serrano’s legacy extends beyond this rivalry, she deserves the chance to even the score. A third fight could finally settle the debate. Until then, her achievements as a boxing pioneer and her dominance in the ring will stand tall—regardless of the judges’ decisions.
