Should the Philadelphia Phillies Take a Chance on Former Cy Young Winner Shane Bieber?

Aiming to Recruit New Talent

As the new MLB season approaches, the Philadelphia Phillies are looking to bolster their roster , particularly in the area of ​​pitching . One potential option being considered is Shane Bieber , a former Cy Young Award winner from the American League . While pitching may not be the Phillies’ top priority, acquiring a talent like Bieber could have a significant impact on the team’s performance .

Current Status of the Phillies

Under the leadership of Dave Dombrowski , the Phillies have shown a clear commitment to improving their roster . While their pitching rotation may not seem like a pressing concern, having an ace could bring some much-needed stability and power to the team. Recent reports suggest that the Phillies are actively targeting high-profile names on the trade market, indicating a willingness to invest in their future.

One potential target for the Phillies is Garrett Crochet of the Chicago White Sox . While the deal could benefit the team, it comes with a hefty price tag. Chicago’s high demands for top talent could make things difficult for Philadelphia, forcing them to explore other options—like Shane Bieber.

Shane Bieber: A Promising Former Cy Young Winner

Shane Bieber won the AL Cy Young Award in 2020, posting an impressive 1.63 ERA , eight wins in 12 appearances, and 122 strikeouts . He also won the prestigious Triple Crown that year. However, injuries, including recent Tommy John surgery , have hampered his career, leaving him a low-profile figure on the free-agent market despite his immense potential.

Spotrac estimates Bieber’s market value at $24.5 million per year, which equates to a six-year, $147 million contract. If the Phillies pursue Bieber, they’ll have to carefully consider their financial position and determine whether they can commit to a player with such a high price tag.

Explore Short Term Contracts

Bieber may be leaning toward a short-term deal to prove his worth after his injury. The Phillies could offer a one-year, $25 million deal with two-way options , providing a balanced solution. This arrangement would allow Bieber to showcase his skills while giving the Phillies a quality pitcher without the long-term financial risk.

Such a deal would benefit both parties. The Phillies would get a seasoned and talented pitcher, while Bieber could compete in a prestigious organization known for developing elite pitching talent. What’s more, this opportunity could position Bieber to pursue a World Series —a prized goal for any player.

Addressing Other Team Needs

While pursuing Bieber is an attractive option, the Phillies also need to consider other areas that need improvement, such as the outfield and bullpen . Prioritizing strategy is important to ensure that the team’s resources are allocated effectively.

If the Phillies decide not to pursue Bieber, they can still focus on other goals in the offseason. Having clear priorities will help them build a stronger, more well-rounded roster for the long term.

Strategic Analysis and Potential Advantages

Adding Bieber to the lineup would give the Phillies a competitive advantage. If he can return to his best form, the team would have a top-notch pitcher who could boost their playoff aspirations . That advantage is important, as seen in last season’s success, where pitching consistency can make a big difference.

Furthermore, signing a player like Bieber could make Philadelphia a more attractive destination for other free agents . Talented pitchers could be lured by the opportunity to play alongside one of the league’s best players, creating a domino effect that could further strengthen the roster.

Towards Success

Philadelphia has a golden opportunity to bolster its roster by taking a chance on former Cy Young winner Shane Bieber . Despite the injury risks, signing him at the right price could yield big rewards. However, careful consideration of financial flexibility and other priorities is essential.

Building a Bright Future

With strategic moves and quality player acquisitions, the Phillies could quickly establish themselves as a serious contender in the MLB . A promising roster bolstered by key additions will position the team to compete for the ultimate goal—a championship trophy .

As the 2025 season approaches, Philadelphia appears poised to lay the foundation for sustained success. The pursuit of Shane Bieber not only provides immediate improvement, but also reflects the organization’s long-term vision. If the Phillies can execute on these plans, they could significantly improve their ability to compete and succeed in the seasons to come.