Jinder Mahal vs. Drew McIntyre: Who’s the real top star? Is Jinder’s rise a fluke, or is Drew overrated? Full story below!

When two WWE heavyweights like Jinder Mahal and Drew McIntyre face off, it’s not just about the championship; it’s a battle for supremacy. Fans are always eager to debate who is truly deserving of being called the top star in WWE, and the rivalry between Mahal and McIntyre has become the perfect microcosm of that question. Is Jinder Mahal’s rise to the top simply a fluke, or does he genuinely belong at the top of WWE? Meanwhile, Drew McIntyre has a reputation that precedes him—his talent, work ethic, and dedication are undeniable, but does he truly deserve to be the face of WWE, or is he just another overrated superstar?

Jinder Mahal’s Rise to the Top: A Fluke or a Masterstroke?

Jinder Mahal’s journey to the WWE Championship is one of the most controversial stories in modern wrestling. When he first arrived in WWE, he was nothing more than a mid-card wrestler with a generic character. But in 2017, Mahal’s fortunes changed in a major way. He suddenly found himself in a championship feud with Randy Orton, culminating in an unexpected win at Backlash 2017, where he became WWE Champion.

For many fans, Jinder Mahal’s rise seemed like a fluke—an improbable story that defied expectations. Critics argued that Mahal didn’t have the in-ring ability or charisma to hold such a prestigious title. His reign was filled with questionable booking decisions, including the constant interference from his cohorts, the Singh Brothers, and a heavy reliance on cheap tactics. Some even labeled his victory as a mere marketing strategy aimed at appealing to Indian fans, given Mahal’s background and his ties to the Indian market.

But to dismiss Jinder Mahal as just a fluke would be a disservice to his ability to capitalize on the opportunity he was given. Mahal’s rise to the top may have seemed unlikely, but he made the most of it. His heel persona, while controversial, played into his reign as WWE Champion. Mahal embraced the role of the cocky, arrogant champion, and while it wasn’t universally loved, it was effective in keeping fans talking. For all the criticism that his title run received, it also created a lot of buzz—something WWE always strives to achieve.

Drew McIntyre: WWE’s Future or Just Another Overhyped Superstar?

Drew McIntyre is often hailed as one of the most talented and dedicated performers in WWE today. After a lackluster initial run in the company, McIntyre reinvented himself as a powerhouse and eventually rose to the top, winning the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 36. His hard work, mental toughness, and raw athleticism have earned him a fanbase that’s fiercely loyal. But is all the praise warranted, or is McIntyre just another overrated superstar?

To his credit, McIntyre has done everything right since his return to WWE. He transformed his body, refined his in-ring skills, and became the embodiment of a WWE champion—commanding the spotlight with his charisma and intensity. His match against Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 36 was a defining moment in his career, and it was a huge moment for fans who had been clamoring for him to be recognized as a top star. McIntyre has since defended the WWE Championship against a number of formidable opponents, cementing his place as one of WWE’s premier performers.

But despite his undeniable success, there are some who argue that Drew McIntyre’s run has been inflated. He was handed the WWE Championship during the pandemic era, and many fans feel that he hasn’t had the chance to truly shine in front of a live audience. McIntyre’s matches, while exciting, sometimes lack the emotional depth or storytelling that other top stars bring to the table. Some critics argue that his crowd connection is lacking, with many fans struggling to fully buy into him as the top star in the company.

So, is Drew McIntyre the real deal, or is he just another overrated WWE superstar who benefited from timing? While it’s clear that McIntyre has star potential, the true test of his legacy will come when he’s forced to compete at the highest level against other established top stars in front of live crowds.

Jinder Mahal vs. Drew McIntyre: Who Really Deserves to Win?

The rivalry between Jinder Mahal and Drew McIntyre isn’t just a clash of physicality—it’s a battle for respect and legacy. Both men have faced their fair share of criticism, but they also have undeniable strengths. Jinder Mahal has proven that he can rise to the occasion when given the chance, while Drew McIntyre has the athleticism and work ethic to remain at the top for years to come.

In the end, both superstars have the potential to leave lasting legacies in WWE. However, Drew McIntyre may have the edge due to his dedication, in-ring ability, and overall commitment to improving his craft. That said, Jinder Mahal’s impact—albeit controversial—cannot be overlooked. Whether or not he’s the top star, his reign and rise to the top were a major talking point in WWE history, and in many ways, he remains an underrated force in the company.

The Battle for Supremacy

As Jinder Mahal and Drew McIntyre continue their careers in WWE, the question of who is the true top star remains unanswered. Both men have their strengths and weaknesses, but their rivalry offers fans the chance to witness two vastly different paths to greatness. Who will ultimately come out on top? Only time will tell, but one thing is for certain—Jinder Mahal vs. Drew McIntyre is a battle that fans won’t soon forget.