Mets Are Throwing Pete Alonso Under the Bus Should Juan Soto Be Worried About Steve Cohen’s Loyalty

When Pete Alonso and the New York Mets engage in contract talks, it’s no longer just a negotiation—it’s a full-blown game of hardball. As Alonso faces uncertainty over his future in Queens, it’s a stark reminder that loyalty in Major League Baseball is often conditional, even for beloved players. The once solid idea of Mets loyalty now seems increasingly fragile, especially when considering the contract negotiations of key figures like Alonso. Will this shake up Juan Soto’s commitment to Steve Cohen’s empire?

Soto’s $765 Million Decision: A High-Risk Gamble

The Mets’ decision to secure Juan Soto with the largest contract in MLB history—a staggering 15-year, $765 million deal—is undeniably a win for the organization. However, while the deal might seem like a solid investment for getting the best of Soto’s prime years, the risks are not negligible. It’s a massive gamble, but one that the Mets were willing to take. Soto, after all, is set to earn over a billion dollars before the end of his career, and it’s hard to ignore the financial incentives that shaped his choice. After all, who could pass up that level of financial security? For Soto, the decision was ultimately about money, and the Mets’ ability to offer the most generous terms made it an easy choice.

The Illusion of ‘Family Atmosphere’: Mets’ Tactics Exposed

While money undoubtedly played a central role in Soto’s choice, another reason often cited is the culture fostered by Steve Cohen’s Mets organization. The Mets promised a “family atmosphere” with perks like private suites and premium tickets for Soto’s family—a stark contrast to the environment he experienced with the New York Yankees. The Mets presented themselves as a more hospitable home, ensuring that Soto and his family would be treated like royalty. Yet, we must consider that this gesture, while seemingly heartwarming, is more of a negotiating tactic than a true commitment to player welfare. In MLB, loyalty can be easily bought—especially when a player like Soto brings in such immense talent and potential value.

Pete Alonso’s Value Under Siege: Mets’ Short-Term Gamble

However, for players like Pete Alonso, the Mets’ approach appears to be much less generous. Despite being a beloved figure in New York—affectionately known as the “Polar Bear”—Alonso is struggling to secure the long-term contract that many thought was a sure thing. A key player for the Mets with multiple All-Star appearances and the MLB home run title, Alonso has been nothing short of dominant. Yet, as of January, he’s still without a new contract, with the Mets exploring short-term deals rather than locking him down for the long haul. Alonso’s value should not be underestimated, but it’s clear that the Mets are playing hardball, pushing for a short-term arrangement that could ultimately leave the star player out in the cold.

Hardball Negotiations: Mets’ Tight Grip on Alonso’s Future

With Steve Cohen at the helm, the Mets should have no trouble affording Alonso’s contract demands. However, it’s not about money anymore—it’s about control. The Mets are squeezing Alonso, and they have given him an ultimatum: Sign a short-term deal and prove yourself again next year, or risk being left out of the plans entirely. Despite Alonso’s proven power and value, the Mets are reluctant to offer him the long-term security he’s earned. It’s clear that loyalty, once thought to be a cornerstone of the Mets’ philosophy, has been replaced by a far more transactional approach.

Juan Soto: A Reality Check in the Making

Juan Soto, currently basking in the glow of a multi-million-dollar contract, should pay close attention to Alonso’s situation. Soto’s guaranteed contract gives him the stability that Alonso is missing, but as we’ve seen with the Mets’ handling of Pete Alonso, the relationship between player and team can shift dramatically if performance doesn’t match the lofty paychecks. Soto’s loyalty to Cohen may be tested sooner than he thinks, as the Mets’ future plans could quickly change if his production starts to slip.

In the end, Soto’s commitment to the Mets should be scrutinized through the lens of Alonso’s contract talks. Loyalty in MLB is fleeting, and it’s likely that Steve Cohen’s Mets will prioritize performance over sentiment when making future decisions. For now, Soto has the luxury of stability, but for how long?