Why the Red Sox Should Wait for Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Instead of Signing Alex Bregman

As the Boston Red Sox continue to search for ways to strengthen their roster ahead of the 2025 season, Chief Baseball Officer Craig Breslow has been working hard to improve the team. While the Red Sox have made significant moves, including acquiring pitchers Garrett Crochet and Walker Buehler, one of the areas that still needs attention is the offense. As part of their efforts, the team has been linked to several star hitters on the free-agent market, including first baseman Pete Alonso, third baseman Alex Bregman, and outfielder Anthony Santander. However, the Red Sox should hold off on signing Bregman and instead pursue Vladimir Guerrero Jr. next offseason. Here’s why.

Alex Bregman and the Potential Fit with the Red Sox

The Red Sox’s need for power in their lineup is well-known, and Alex Bregman has long been considered an intriguing option. Bregman has been the subject of numerous rumors linking him to Boston, primarily because of his relationship with Walker Buehler. While Bregman is an accomplished player, his potential signing could cause some complications for the Red Sox’s infield. Rafael Devers, the current third baseman, would likely be forced to move to first base if Bregman joined the team, something he is willing to do but doesn’t prefer at this point in his career.

Moreover, Bregman might not offer a substantial upgrade over Devers, who is already a dynamic presence at third base. This could make a potential move for Bregman less appealing for the Red Sox, especially when their roster could benefit from a more pressing upgrade at first base.

Why Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Makes More Sense for the Red Sox

On the other hand, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., known as “Vladdy”, would be an excellent fit for the Red Sox. Guerrero is expected to hit free agency next offseason, and he could be the long-term solution the team needs at first base. Currently, Triston Casas occupies that spot, but Guerrero would undoubtedly provide a significant upgrade over Casas. His power at the plate and consistent production would greatly improve the Red Sox lineup.

Unlike Bregman, who would cause a positional shuffle in the infield, Guerrero could seamlessly slot into first base without disrupting the current infield dynamic, allowing Devers to stay at third base where he is most comfortable.

The Long-Term Strategy: Patience for a Bigger Upgrade

By waiting for Vladimir Guerrero Jr. to hit the open market, the Red Sox would be making a more strategic, long-term move. Guerrero fits better with the team’s timeline and would provide a better return on investment than Bregman. Given the Red Sox’s current needs, it would be wiser to pass on Bregman and instead set their sights on Vladdy next year.

Conclusion: The Smart Play for the Red Sox

While Alex Bregman may seem like an attractive option for the Boston Red Sox, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. represents a more ideal solution for the future of the team. By waiting for Guerrero to become available, the Red Sox would not only avoid unnecessary positional changes but would also secure a top-tier power hitter at first base. It’s a calculated decision that will pay off in the long run for the team.